As a new investor, you will hear the terms mutual funds, stocks, bonds, etc. But you may be wondering what's the difference. The perpetual fight between mutual funds vs stocks plagues all investors. So, let's understand the pros and cons of both and which is a better investment.
Mutual funds are pooled investments that contain multiple stocks and other assets within that single fund. An experienced Fund Manager manages this pool. Any income or gains generated from these collective investments is distributed among investors post the deduction of applicable expenses.
Mutual funds are known to offer stability in a portfolio but are not foolproof.
Pros of Mutual Funds:
Cons of Mutual Funds:
A stock is the ownership of shares in a corporation or company. When companies such as Amazon and Tesla do well, those holding stocks benefit. As the company grows, the stock prices for that company go up. This gives investors an added income to sell the shares for more than they bought.
Stocks provide an invaluable way to grow wealth and take advantage of big-cost moves.
Pros of Stocks:
Cons of Stocks:
When it comes to the fight between mutual funds vs stocks, the key differences are:
1. Mutual funds are a pool of money from multiple small investors invested in a portfolio of multiple assets. This can include aspects like money market instruments, debt or equity. At the same time, a stock is a collection of shares owned by individual investors that indicates ownership of assets in the company.
2. The performance of mutual funds depends on macroeconomic factors, where the fund manager's skills and security pool helps maintain regular and stable returns. Stock performance depends on the company's performance.
3. The rules and regulations in mutual funds are stated as per the Red Herring Prospectus. These rules are meant to beat the returns the market provides without impacting the invested principal amount. On the other hand, a Board of Directors determines stock strategies. These can change based on the market and the director's skills.
4. Mutual funds provide fractional ownership in the overall basket, whereas stocks represent ownership stakes to investors.
5. Mutual funds are managed by fund managers, whereas investors are individually responsible for managing their own stocks.
6. The risk components in mutual funds provide diversification benefits; this offers a robust earning opportunity in case a single company fails. In contrast, the risk component in stocks is larger as it is based on a single company.
7. Mutual funds are traded only once a day when the NAV is finalized, whereas stock trading takes place at all times during the day.
8. Value of a mutual fund is calculated by arriving at NAV - the total value of Net Asset Expenses. But, the total cost of shares is based on an individual share price multiplied by the total number of shares.
9. Mutual funds provide regular dividends to investors, with a periodic statement on the performance of the funds. On the other hand, stocks give regular returns in the form of dividends earned and vary depending on the firm's performance.
10. For mutual funds, the fund manager is not directly responsible for the funds' outcome. In contrast, the stockholder is responsible for returns in the stock market as the investor is directly managed by the same.
Mutual Funds | Stocks | |
Meaning | Group of shares held by investors that indicate ownership | Shares from a single corporation held by an investor |
Ownership | Shares on a collective group of funds | Shares in a single company |
Diversification | Across multiple shares and companies | Limited to one company |
Risks | Low - protection through diverse shares | High - Performance is based on a single company |
Costs | Based on NAV or Net Asset Value | Price of share in the market |
Hidden Costs | High management fees | No hidden fees after the purchase |
Trading | Only at the end of the day | Throughout the day |
Customization | As decided by a fund manager | Investors can choose the stocks they want |
Beginner Friendliness | High - no knowledge required | Low-intensive research required |
Commission Incurred | Commission paid at entry, exit or both times | Paid when stocks are traded |
For long-term investors, mutual funds are the best option as it reduces any overall risk and helps create a retirement plan. These are also perfect for beginner investors who want to enter the stock market but do not know much about it.
For investors who want to capture a company's potential growth, individual stocks provide the option for bigger returns. Investors can go this route to stomach more risks and be confident in analyzing individual stocks.
When investing in mutual funds vs stocks finally comes down to investment goals and risk tolerances. The main difference between these is the number of funds, and diversity is always considered a solid investment.
Investing in mutual funds vs stocks is an entirely personal decision, and the investor should understand the pros and cons of each. Both these options are easily available for investors with the limited requirement. But stocks offer the option to invest directly in the stock market, but one needs to track the performance to decide the future course.
On the other side, mutual funds are based on diversification. It helps get the risks to get spread out, and professionals can manage these funds within the ambit of strategies that are committed. So, investors are relieved of the idea of constantly monitoring the investment.